Does PCA Work for Rough Functional Data?

Functional data analysis is concerned with the analysis of infinite-dimensional data functions. Functional principal component analysis (FPCA) is a key method to obtain finite-dimensional summaries. Consistency of FPCA has been theoretically established for sufficiently regular data functions. However, empirical evidence shows that FPCA can become severely inconsistent when the underlying functions are too rough. This paper provides the first theoretical explanation for this phenomenon. We propo